The Ledger Letter: The Argument Ended Friday. Stocks Rallied Anyway.
One tenth of a percentage point moved the odds fifteen points. The Dow went up.
The Ledger Letter
Finance Studio Advisors
Market Intelligence Partner
Image
I’m about to do a live demonstration.
Of Elon Musk’s latest genius invention.
It’s an AI agent…
Perhaps the most powerful ever created.
Elon himself believes it could 70x your money… in a short period of time.

The Argument Ended Friday. Stocks Rallied Anyway.

August core prices rose 0.3% for the month, a tenth above consensus. Hike odds went from roughly 72% on Thursday to near 87% by Friday midday. Capital Economics said the committee now looks set to move. Nationwide switched to expecting a quarter point. And the Dow closed up 527 points. The rate question got its answer. The stock market threw a party.
The Breakdown
This week’s disagreement, settled and reopened: the rate market got its answer on Friday; the equity market decided the answer was good news.
01
What Printed
Headline CPI rose 0.4% for the month and 3.4% on the year, both in line. Core rose 0.3%, a tenth above forecast, with the annual rate at 2.4%. Gasoline rose 3.9% in August and accounted for over a third of the monthly increase, per BLS.
02
What It Moved
CME FedWatch went from about 72% on Thursday to near 87% by Friday midday, which is 87 against 13. October follow-on odds ran to roughly 60%. Deutsche Bank now models two quarter-point moves this year. Bank of America models three.
03
What Stocks DidThe Dow closed up 527 points. The other majors finished green with it. That is the equity tape rallying on the session that made a hike the base case, five days before the vote.
How the Week Closed
Sept Hike OddsNear 87 against 13
Core CPI+0.3% m/m, 2.4% y/y
Headline CPI+0.4% m/m, 3.4% y/y
Dow Jones+527 points
Fed Target Range3.50% to 3.75%
DecisionWednesday, September 16
Friday, Sept. 11. Odds are a market price rather than a forecast, quoted at midday and volatile through the session. Sources: BLS; CME FedWatch; CNBC; NBC News.

One Tenth of a Point

What the Number Actually Said

The headline was dull. Prices rose 0.4% on the month and 3.4% on the year, exactly where the Street had them. The whole event sat in one decimal place. Core, which strips out food and energy, rose 0.3% against a 0.2% consensus. That is a single tenth. It was enough. Core is the trend the committee tracks, and energy is the part it treats as weather.

Who Changed Their Mind

Yesterday morning this letter set the argument as the market against the forecasters. By the afternoon the forecasters had folded. Capital Economics said the upside surprise leaves the Fed set to move. Nationwide now expects a quarter point. Deutsche Bank models two hikes this year, Bank of America three. Heather Long of Navy Federal put it in six words: “America still has an inflation problem.” The consensus moved to the tape, not the reverse.

Why Stocks Went the Other Way

Then the Dow put on 527 points. There are two readings and they lead opposite places. The generous one says certainty beats direction. A market that knows it gets a hike can finally price the rest of the year. The harsh one says equities are treating a hiking cycle as a one-off. They treated five sessions of selling as a dip too. Note what gasoline did in that print. Up 3.9% in a single month, carrying over a third of the increase. Energy is the one input a rate rise cannot touch.

The Level to Watch Wednesday

The committee meets Tuesday and votes Wednesday. At 87 against 13, a hike is close to fully in the price, so the move itself is no longer the event. The event is the language and the projections. Watch whether October gets guided toward or away from the roughly 60% the market now carries. If the statement points at a second move, equities have to re-read Friday completely. If it points at one and done, the rally was early rather than wrong.

The forecasters surrendered on Friday. The stock market celebrated. Only one of those was reading the same report.

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right